Pros & Cons on different game engines

チーズパン
  • Pros & Cons on different game engines チーズパン

    I've been working with the XNA-Framework(only in 2D) for over a year now. Now I want to try and start a bigger 3D-project. But somehow I have difficulties to decide which engine/Framework I should use. So far I gathered three possible Frameworks, I want to list here:

    1. XNA with the OX-engine: I already have some experience with XNA and the Ox-engine seems to be the best possible open source engine I could use here.

    2. OGRE-engine: Always wanted to get a little deeper into C++ and the engine seems to be well documented.

    3. Cryengine/Sandbox 2 or higher: Well this one also needs C++ knowledge, seems to be user friendly and lets face it one of the most powerful engines out there.

    My goals are to start learning 3D-programming and to realize first 3D projects by taking baby steps.

    So the question is what engine would you guys recommend? Is there any other stuff I have overseen? as mentioned before getting a little more into C++ would be great to but it is not a "must have" as I alredy worked with C/C#. Most important to me would be that I could lear stuff that I can use later on for example in other Frameworks. This is important to me because I want to get deep into one thing I will be doing for a long time.

    Thanks in advance!

  • You could use Unity3D, you can write your script in C#.

    I haven't seen the Ox-engine before, but it seems that the last source checkin was over a year ago. I wonder if the project is still active..

  • For starting, begin with free version of Unity3d, and start learning DirectX 11 or OpenGL in parallel.

  • It really depends on what you want to do. Is it a game? Then use an engine like Unity. If you want to learn 3D programming and math from the ground, writing your own tech demos could work. Remember that engines are tools, nothing more, nothing less.

    The DirectX vs OpenGL doesn't matter, pick one, learn it and you will easily change to the other. If you want to learn one of these start your own demo project from scratch, but don't expect being able to finish a game with it. If you just want to learn the graphics programming part of it, using any tool that supports writing shader code directly will work. Like Unity support Cg.

    Note also that Cryengine is only just released. It doesn't have a large community or documentation yet. Unreal, while maybe more limited, does give you that.

Tags
c++ graphics-programming
Related questions and answers
  • etc. are far worse in Flash, than they are in XNA/WPF.) Now, I'm aware that I could make my own engine that supports each of those platforms, but quite frankly, that would be too much work plowing through APIs. After all, I want to make a game, not an engine. So the question becomes: Is there maybe a cross platform (free or free to develop?) engine available that I could use for 2D development... don't really need 3D. The editor usability is a little worse than Unity3D in my opinion and it wasn't clear to me how to start programming. I think it requires C++ for coding, so that's a negative too. I

  • know if my speculations are ok, as I don't have much experience with 3d animations yet. I want to make a well decision as any option I choose would require a lot of work to get it to render and I...well... I'm building the animation system of my game engine (the skeletal and skinned animation stuff), and I came to a point where I added so much functionality in the frame and node structures... shader in every node. Other option I was thinking was making some helper functions to deal with the simpler cases, which would set some default parameters and would ask only the most basic ones

  • I have the book iPhone 3D Programming; this book taught be a lot about overall c++ iPhone application architecture and iPhone OpenGL ES. But a lot of the book is obviously about 3D, so most of the book wasn't that useful to me. I also have Game Coding Complete 3rd Edition; this book taught me a lot about game engine architecture but the emphasis is on c++ windows desktop game programming. I am looking for c++ 2D game engine architecture books. I'm not looking to use any frameworks; I want something more geared towards 2d c++ game engine architecture. Any suggestions? Thanks.

  • hey so I've decided to Code my own 2D soft-body physics engine in C++ since apparently none exist and I'm starting only with a general idea/understanding on how physics work and could be simulated... examples/sites that could give me the specifics needed to actually make this such as equations and required physics knowledge. It would be great if anyone out there also would give me their attempts or ideas. finally I was wondering if it was possible to... use the source code of an existing 3D engine such as Bullet and transform it to be 2D based? use the source code of a 2D Rigid body physics

  • Say I develop a game for mobile platform running OpenGL ES 2.0. I have done 2D part, and now I wish to import some 3D objects. The imported 3D objects must contain the following: Vertices positions Normals UVs Texturing information Animation information Collision mesh Maybe some other things... I am aware, that I could and (maybe should) create my own file format that brings these data from..., that will let me import 3d meshes into my game, ready to use? The solution/middleware should be: easy to use easy to port efficient not consuming too much memory with unnecessary things containing all

  • in the world. I'm OK at C++ but its one language I would really like to explore and make my primary language. (assuming there are jobs for grads in this area) This project will most likely define the career... would have the most insight. So just an introduction to myself and the problem. Basically Im in my final year of my degree and rather than do a thesis we do a final year project that has to be crisp... this summer and I have a good grounding on the web side of things. I've also done some very basic c++ (what i would consider basic). My c++ skills basically comes down to different tutorials on things

  • I would like to know if there is a C++ game engine that I can use for free to prototype some ideas I have. I have experience in C++ and have spent some time now playing around with different rendering engines such as Ogre3d and irrlicht. I don't want to re-invent the wheel and spend the time building my own engine. I have some ideas for a game that I would like to prototype and would be looking... a time limit on free use. By all inclusive I mean: I would rather not have to get a whole bunch of separate dependencies for physics, sound etc. I would prefer the one engine to have those things

  • Suppose I have a Spacecraft object in 3D space, controllable by the player. I want it to update its own trajectory, so I give it a function for that (actually it might be inside a controller component associated with it). No problem until this point. For this function I want to use a scientifically tested, accurate N-body simulation algorithm (like this). It's my field so I already know how to do that. The challenge is how to make the game activate the function efficiently. This is what I've thought of so far: The algorithm can calculate a lot of time steps in a short time, so I could

  • Everybody heard about the release of the Quake3 source code. But since it's plain C but uses OOP a little, isn't it too complex to decipher or to use for large projects such as a 3rd person shooter/hack&slash with smooth camera movements ? Would it be a good idea to use it instead of Ogre, I want to be sure it's really harder to use since it's only an engine dedicated to FPS. Ogre seems... the release of the quake3 engine changed for open source developpers (except the infamous invsqrt method). I heard Carmack released it for students or people alike, but C++ is here: is quake3's code